Yippee! Free Shipping on orders over $50

EEK! Eyeballs you can eat! Spook your friends with the most delicious eyeball cake bites!


Bake your cake mix as directed in a 9x13 pan and let cool. Once cooled crumble the cake with your fingers into a large bowl. Crumble the cake until you no longer have any large chunks. Stir in your frosting and roll into 1" balls, you should get about 50. Place the rolled balls on a wax paper lined cookie sheet and refrigerate until firm. Melt your candy melts and 1/4 cup paramount crystals in the microwave on 15-30 second intervals checking and stirring them in-between. Do not overheat! Dunk your cake balls in the melted candy melts using a fork and gently tap the handle of your fork to encourage any excess candy melt to drip off. Using another fork scoot your cake ball onto your wax paper lined cookie sheet and immediately top with a jumbo icing eye. When dry place in mini black baking cups and serve!

 Packaging Suggestion 

Place your eyeball cake bites in mini black baking cups, and nestle into white window cookie boxes. You can fit about 4 cake bites per box. Tie up your boxes with black bakers twine and label grey paper tags with the lucky recipients name.


1 Box of Cake Mix or Homemade Cake
1 16oz. Can of Frosting or 2 Cups Homemade Frosting
Wax Paper Lined Cookie Sheet
and the following..

Join our Mailing List

Hey there darling, don't miss out on our FUN and INSPIRING weekly email!